i’m going to admit, right here, right now: sometimes, i have no idea why i’m married.
the thing is, i’m not alone. i was reading bitch ph.d’s analysis of sandra tsing-loh’s piece in the atlantic the other day. they both talk about the impossible standards we as a society set for marriage, the upshot of which is:
The Good Marriage is Supposed to be:
sexually monogamous
between one man and one woman (even though, or rather because, men and women Are Different)
for their entire lives
begun early enough that they can have children, plural, (if they want to), without having to go through infertility treatment
passionate, again, for their entire lives
respectful at all times
mutually supportive, at all times
economically successful
able to accommodate two careers, if so desired
a friendship
something you “work” at, but it’s not supposed to feel like work
flirty–but only with each other
not jealous
a PIllar of Society
more than these unwritten rules, as a society, we bully, cajole, and shame people into *never, ever admitting there might god-forbid possible be anything wrong* with our perfect unions. it starts when we’re young, when we feed children fairytales about “soulmates” and fateful signs like magic glass slippers that are supposed to tell you s/he’s “the one”. men grow up believing they must be strong protectors and providers, and women grow up fantasizing about their wedding day.
if i’m honest, in my heart of hearts, i think it’s all bullshit.
my parents divorced after 20 years of marriage, in spectacular meltdown fashion. i got married early, and divorced even earlier. the idea that we’re bound to be with just one person in a world of over 6 billion is ludicrous. the idea that we will stay in love with one person into old age is ridiculously improbable. that all the vicissitudes of children, and careers, and money, and sex, and health, and family… that all that will leave our personas unchanged, leave our relationships untouched… well, it’s bullshit. change is inescapable and impossible to predict. what on earth makes us think that the way we feel about each other is immune to those kinds of seismic forces?
and yet, we’re not allowed to ever admit to imperfections. to be brutally honest and say that there are days when we would happily walk out the door. to allow that, hell yes, it feels like work sometimes. that sometimes we deliberately inflict pain, and sometimes we are cruel and nasty and take it out of the other person for no good reason. or that even worse, we too argue about the indescribably mundane money and sex. that some days we fantasize about being someone different, being with someone different, however fleeting. and i say “we” with confidence, because i know i am not alone. people who say they never think or feel that way are flat-out lying.
we have unachievable expectations of our relationships, and unbelieveable guilt when we don’t meet them.
being in a relationship where you have to keep up pretenses that everything is always okay, all the time, is exhausting and incredibly isolating, and it puts every other couple under additional pressure to do the same. it’s so incredibly, pathetically phoney. when my first marriage was crumbing, we knew sometime after thanksgiving that it was over. and yet, we decided not to tell anyone in our families until well into the new year, for fear of “ruining their holidays”. so we pretended for 3 more months to keep up appearances. much worse than the breakup, was the amount of control it took not to break down during those three months. i look back on that time and think…why?
but for some reason, we continue to perpetuate this illusion. for those who are single, we don’t want to sour them against the dream of an ideal partnership. and for those who are paired, we don’t want to admit that our relationship might not measure up against (our perceived image of) theirs. no one wants to be the first to admit to shortcomings. the stakes are too high – when we live in a society that has invested so much in the construct of marriage, foibles are not allowed.
even when anyone who’s ever been in a long term relationship knows they are very, very real.
marriage is a fantasy that the reality can never live up to, and the odds start out against you and only get worse as time goes on – as personalities and pettiness and pedestrian problems grate. even under the best of circumstance, the statistics tell us there’s only a 50/50 chance you’ll make it. so yes, there are days when i have no idea why the hell i’m married. through a combination of work (yes, work), luck, and grace on the part of my significant other, they are exceedingly rare. i am, in the main, very happy. and against all odds, i hope to stay that way. (even as i write that, it feels like i’m qualifying my previous statement; i’m not, but i don’t wish to alarm readers who know me and my husband in real life!) but every time i paste on a faux happy-wife smile for the sake of others (and i freely admit to having done that), i wonder who i’m doing the greater disservice to: myself or my audience?
in spite of all the bullshit that goes with being married, and all the bullshit i admit to participating in, and all the bullshit beliefs we buy into… i’m still married, and glad of it. i feel like i shouldn’t say that after my diatribe above, but i’d be lying if i didn’t. so while i will admit to days when i don’t know why i’m a participant in this crazy and unrealistic institution, i will also admit to wanting to believe in it with all my heart.
in a world where 50% of all marriages end up crashing and burning… there’s also 50% who stay together. we all line up at the altar thinking we’re in that other half, and we don’t complain about the glass slipper that pinches, because hell, at least we’ve found one that almost fits, so we should just shuddup and feel lucky already.
and even though i may not like the odds, it seems i’m willing to play them all the same.
revelator – gillian welch
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.