Peace is the only battle worth waging – Albert Camus (1913-1960)
this weekend is memorial day weekend in the states. and that means a lot of “support our troops” emails are making the rounds. several of them have made it into my inbox, and i find myself grappling with how to respond.
it’s a bit of a touchy subject for me – one i find hard to explain without coming across as coldhearted. i don’t usually do it very well, so i’ll attempt to make a better job of it here.
when i read about people lost to the war, of course i find it sad. it’s incredibly sad. it’s even more tragic because i think it’s wholly unnecessary. but even though i don’t want anyone else to die (please, don’t let anyone else die), as a pacifist i can’t bring myself to say i “support the troops”. to my mind, to condone the existence of the military is to condone the machinery of war and death. as a pacifist, i don’t believe in the military, i don’t believe in guns. i don’t believe anyone should have to “fight for me”, much less die for me. i can’t say i’m “proud of them” because i don’t believe anyone should ever kill, even in self defense. i don’t believe the government has the right to take a life, under any circumstances. i don’t think death should ever be a source of pride. i can’t say i “appreciate what they do for us”, because they don’t do it for me – i’ve not asked them to, and i don’t want them to.
i therefore also refuse to believe that i should show gratitude towards those who support an institution i don’t agree with. lots of people find that offensive, but there you have it. i don’t believe in a military and i don’t feel indebted to those who’re part of it.
that doesn’t mean i don’t want them to come home safe and alive. i hate this war and i hate the wasted lives it has spilled. not just american lives, but all lives. memorial day (and remembrance day) for me means reflecting upon what a colossal tragedy it is that we’re still running around killing each other over politics, religion, land. that anyone should die for such
most people (even most of those who’re anti-war) still feel there’s a need for the military, that they serve a valuable function – and that’s something i can’t reconcile with my beliefs. i disagree with the fundamental premise that the military is a necessary institution. most people find that position naive and hopelessly idealistic. it probably is.
i am very much aware that my opinion is in the minority – i have no desire to try to convert people or defend my beliefs. most everyone i know disagrees with me, and that’s fine. personally, i think i’m in pretty good company.
but even if I am wrong, i’m not going to change my core values, simply to match “reality”. call me naive, call me unrealistic, call me what you will. but they said the same thing about Gandhi’s, Martin Luther King’s, the Quakers’s (dare i say, even Jesus’s) belief in the power of non-violent protest. so i’ll continue to side with peace, no matter how foolish such a simple option may seem, no matter how difficult to understand.
fellow pacifist Albert Einstein famously said: “You cannot simultaneously prevent and prepare for war. The very prevention of war requires more faith, courage and resolution than are needed to prepare for war. We must all do our share, that we may be equal to the task of peace.” that comes closest to saying in a nutshell what i feel at the centre of my soul, what i will never waver from.
and what i will be thinking about this memorial day.
the submarines – peace and hate
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
memorial day, pacifism